that's interesting loup. my school district had tried to do something similar, but it was in a very low-income area and most students couldn't realistically attend the school that was best-suited for their interests. the schools were originally meant to be grouped into orientation towards future professions. one school was supposed to be oriented towards mechanical and manual work, another towards technology, another towards health sciences, and finally one towards entrance into high-profile universities. but with such limited resources, the whole program fell apart.
my particular HS was very low-performing HS, and CA itself has a very troubled pre-college education system. i was identified "gifted" at a very early age, but i wasn't accelerated through any grades (my mom worried about my social development). instead i was put into special classes and such -- which in hindsight may have been worse. skipping a grade might have afforded me the opportunity to 'fit in' with a group of slightly older kids. being singled out as special and removed from the normal class only made me more of an outsider.
in HS, pretty much all of my general ed classes were honors or advanced placement. i finished calculus in 10th grade, and i slept through or ditched most of my english classes. i was bored. i participated in a large number of extracurricular activities (academic decathlon, model U.N., student body government, a few sports, and a few other clubs) and took lots of electives. i didn't realize it at the time, but it was learning and creating, in general, that i found really fulfilling, and i simply wasn't learning much in my general ed courses.
in college i started taking upper-division classes in the spring trimester of my first year. i enrolled in "Collective Memory", a special topics course offered by the sociology department. there were about 20 people in the course, and very few lectures. people discussed readings, events, and their own ideas, work and experiences. we traded ideas and worked together to create understanding and interpret the ideas of others. i was in love. it also helped that other people in the class complimented me and my statements outside of class. it was a very encouraging and positive experience, and i continued taking upper-division courses and putting off my general education ones for the next 3 years. eventually i'd taken so many sociology classes that i pretty much had to major in the discipline. i still slacked for a while, getting C's and B's, but at some point during my 3rd year i found focus and decided to start really applying myself. i applied to the honors program in sociology and found myself conducting an 18-month field research project on the relationship between body art and self-identity in modern society. it was grueling, especially since during my 5 years there my parents separated, my mom experienced a psychotic break, my father passed away, and my brother developed a brief drug problem. but i came out of it (college, that is-not those personal trials) with a strong sense of accomplishment. i've never had that feeling from other jobs i've worked, and now that i've worked several more i know that teaching and research is where i want to, no, have to be.
it's true that i wouldn't have found that without going to college, but it's also true that i wouldn't have been so sure without the experiences i've gained since then. the thing is, i might've spent less time taking (and often dropping) totally random classes if i'd had a little more preparation for academic culture. HS taught me a few basic things and exposed me to many more, but never enough to know what my calling is. i'm not sure that would've happened with any forumlation of an education during those years. i was simply too young.
so i guess what i'm saying is that i worry that giving students the option to rush directly into a vaction/profession/life-path is that they'll do it before really knowing themselves, and be more likely to lock themselves into career fields they dislike, but also find themselves high and dry for the resources and support they'd need to change their lives' paths.