I have purchased Start8 and installed it, and HURRAY, I have my Start Menu back!!!
However, one of the most valuable functions of the Start Menu for me is the recently used programs. In this area, there is definitely room for improvement.
The Microsoft Windows 7 list was very intelligent about keeping track of which programs that I "really" use the most, and bubbling them up to the top of the list.
With the StarDock menu, even though there are some programs that I've recently used dozens of times, a program that I launch only once or twice will bubble up to the top right away.
The app needs to be a bit more intelligent about which programs that I "really" use, versus a simple FIFO approach.
Thanks for a great product!