Ok, heres an update from my end again.
I play in two places, work and home.
At work - I'm behind a symmantec NAT router, and our setup here prohibits me from setting up port forwarding to my IP. I can connect to approximately 20% of the community. I can easily spend 20-30 minutes finding a 2v2 game that I can connect to. 3v3 once in a great while, I've never played a 4v4 or 5v5 game.On my end there is no solution to this problem that I can achieve. If I ever want to play at work (Yeah I know, I'm at work I should be working.. thing is, I'm in video game development so playing games for part of my day IS work).
At home - Router is sorted, I'm usually the first to connect to people who don't suffer from other connection issues themselves. It still takes about 10 minutes to get a game going. Over the weekend I played about a dozen games. Only 2 played out to completion. One was a 3v3 game, the other a 2v2. The other failed attempts were 4v4 games. In each situation with a 4v4 game one of three scenarios played out. I could never successfully get a 5v5 game going (and have yet to actually join a playable one).
1. All users with pings around 80-120 but the game jerked/lagged to the point where its unplayable. Everyone insisted no firewalls or scanning programs were active at the time. After about 5 minutes with the problem getting worse and worse, we all just decided to alt + f4 out.
5 times
2. Finally getting a 4v4 game going with only a little notice-able lag, only to be ejected and shoved into a singleplayer 4v4 match for no discernable reason (?? whats this about??).
2 times
3. Rage quitters on opposite teams deciding that about 10 minutes to cry about *something* and bugger off in a fury.. Remainder of the team leaves after the first one since they know they have no chance. Yes happends to me on my team too, but I'm one of those people who likes to play it out to the end, even if its almost assuredly going to be a loss.
3 times
Frogboy, and you other guys at Stardock - I love you, I love your dedication to your product and your communication to your community. I do hope that connection issues continue to get ironed out because they are still far from what I would consider a "smooth" experience.
I hope to one day be able to hop in and see 4v4 and 5v5 games populating the game lists and know that I can join one and have about an 80% chance to get through it, other than the current 16% chance.